Should I Move to Islington, Highbury, or Holloway? A Comparison Guide

•  

Choosing the right place to live in North London can feel overwhelming, especially when you’re weighing up three neighbouring but very distinct areas: Islington, Highbury, and Holloway. At Stadium Residential, we’ve spent over 80 years combined helping residents navigate these neighbourhoods. With excellent reviews, strong local knowledge, and long-standing partnerships with respected authorities, including Zoopla, Trading Standards, and Propertymark, we have the insight to help you make the right move for your personal wants and needs.

Below, we offer a comprehensive comparison guide to Islington, Highbury, and Holloway, covering lifestyle, amenities, transportation, and which area suits each person best.

Introducing the Areas

Islington

Islington is a really popular area, with culture, dining, nightlife, and easy access to the City and West End. Upper Street is packed with restaurants, boutique shops, theatres, and cafés. For arts lovers, the Almeida Theatre and Sadler’s Wells make Islington a cultural hotspot.

Who it’s for: Professionals, creatives, and families looking for an urban lifestyle with excellent transport links and top-tier amenities.

Local highlights:

• Regent’s Canal walks
•  Islington Green
• Angel Station (Northern Line)
• Coal Drops Yard (nearby, lifestyle shopping district)

Highbury

Highbury is known for its peaceful, residential feel. Tree-lined streets, beautiful period homes, and a strong community atmosphere. It’s perfect for those who want access to green space without compromising on proximity to Central London. Highbury Fields is one of the largest open spaces in the area, and is a favourite with families, runners, and dog owners.

Who it’s for: Families, people upsizing, and professionals wanting a quieter pace with strong transport links.

Local highlights:

• Highbury Fields (Islington’s largest green space)
• Highbury Barn, known for artisan food shops
• Arsenal Station (Piccadilly Line)
• Gillespie Park Nature Reserve 

Holloway

Holloway is one of North London’s most diverse neighbourhoods. It has rapidly grown in popularity due to its excellent value compared to nearby Islington and Highbury. Holloway Road has a growing number of cafes, restaurants, independent shops, and great transportation links. Recent regeneration projects and new developments have attracted young professionals and first-time buyers.

Who it’s for: First-time buyers, young professionals, investors, renters, and anyone seeking significant value in Zone 2.

Local highlights:

• Emirates Stadium
• Holloway Road Station (Piccadilly Line)
• Nag’s Head Shopping Centre
• London Metropolitan University

How the Areas Compare

Lifestyle & Atmosphere

• Islington: Bustling, stylish, cosmopolitan. A great balance of work and play.
• Highbury: Quiet, elegant, family-friendly. Strong sense of community.
• Holloway: Energetic, affordable, diverse. Excellent transport and convenience.

Property Styles

• Islington: Georgian townhouses, Victorian terraces, converted warehouses, modern apartments.
• Highbury: Beautiful period homes, large terraces, mansion blocks, and Victorian conversions.
• Holloway: Mix of Victorian terraces, new-build flats, and modern developments.

Transport

All three areas offer swift connections across London.

• Islington: Angel (Northern Line), Highbury & Islington (Victoria Line + Overground).
• Highbury: Arsenal (Piccadilly Line) and Highbury & Islington Station.
• Holloway: Holloway Road (Piccadilly Line) and Finsbury Park for the Victoria Line.

Schools

Islington and Highbury both benefit from a strong selection of well-rated primary and secondary schools. Holloway also offers a growing number of well-performing academies.

Which Area Should You Choose?

Here’s a quick breakdown based on lifestyle needs:

• Choose Islington if you want a lively, connected neighbourhood with premium amenities and cultural venues on your doorstep.
• Choose Highbury if green space, period homes, and a calmer residential feel are your priorities.
• Choose Holloway if you're looking for value, energy, and excellent transport in a rapidly improving area.

Each area has something unique to offer, and all sit within the same dynamic North London community.

Whether you're drawn to the culture of Islington, the tranquillity of Highbury, or the accessibility and value of Holloway, North London has an area to fit every lifestyle. With decades of combined experience, Stadium Residential is here to help you navigate these neighbourhoods confidently. Our team of local experts, backed by our partnerships with professional bodies and other respected authorities, ensures you receive reliable guidance from start to finish.

Ready to explore properties across these fantastic areas? Contact Stadium Residential today. We are your trusted specialists in North London, with lots of 5-star ratings on Google.